Retirement Ratio
What a Probability of Success Can't Tell You
Why I plan around one number you can act on


If you have ever sat through a retirement plan review, you may have seen a number like this at the end: your plan has an 85% chance of success. (That figure is only an example of how planning software reports results.)
That number usually comes from software that runs your plan through thousands of possible market paths and counts how many of them work out. It is a real tool, and it answers a real question: how likely is this plan to work at this investment mix?
The trouble is what happens next.
What do you do with 85%?
Is 85% good? Should you aim for 90%? Those are fair questions, but they are not the question most people bring to a planning meeting. The question most people bring is simpler: what do my savings need to earn?
A probability answers how likely your plan is to work. That is a different question.
The real goal
The real goal is to see how to invest your savings to meet your withdrawal needs with the least amount of risk required to keep your principal intact.
That calls for a different kind of number.
One number you can act on
The Retirement Ratio is the earnings rate your portfolio needs to fund your retirement spending without drawing down what you saved. It takes two steps:
- Find your annual gap. Take what you expect to spend in a year and subtract your income sources: Social Security, pensions, rental income.
- Divide by your invested assets. That is your Retirement Ratio.
Take a hypothetical household that spends $90,000 a year, has $48,000 in income sources, and has $1,000,000 invested. Its gap is $42,000, and its Retirement Ratio is 4.2%*. Its portfolio needs to earn 4.2%* a year to cover the gap without drawing down principal.
* Example number for illustration only. This is a hypothetical household and does not represent typical or expected results.
Notice what that number lets you do. It turns "how likely am I to be fine?" into "what does my money need to earn?" And that is a question you can make decisions with:
- How to invest. If your portfolio needs to earn a modest rate, there may be no reason to take more risk than that requires.
- When to start Social Security or a pension. Each choice changes your income, so you can see exactly how it changes your ratio.
- What your spending means for your plan. Every dollar of spending moves your gap, and you can see by how much.
When the number is too high
Now take a second hypothetical household. It spends $100,000 a year, has $40,000 in income sources, and has $1,000,000 invested. Its gap is $60,000, so its Retirement Ratio is 6.0%. I like to see the ten-year average below 5%, so this household has work to do.
The ratio shows where to start. Delaying Social Security to raise it to $46,000 a year brings the ratio to 5.4%. Trimming spending by $8,000 a year on top of that brings it to 4.6%. Two specific changes, each with a size you can see.
Neither number is a forecast; both move with assumptions about spending, inflation and returns. The difference is what each one is built to show. A probability tells you the chance your plan works. The Retirement Ratio tells you what your savings need to earn, and how much risk that takes.
Find your own number
I wrote a free guide that walks through the Retirement Ratio with three worked examples. You can get it at wealthbalanceadvisors.com/free-guide.
Or, if you would rather have your own number, a Retirement Ratio Session gives you your ratio for year one and as a ten-year average, a plan in plain English built around it, and clear next steps. You can book one at wealthbalanceadvisors.com/retirement-ratio-session.
If you have ever sat through a retirement plan review, you may have seen a number like this at the end: your plan has an 85% chance of success. (That figure is only an example of how planning software reports results.)
That number usually comes from software that runs your plan through thousands of possible market paths and counts how many of them work out. It is a real tool, and it answers a real question: how likely is this plan to work at this investment mix?
The trouble is what happens next.
What do you do with 85%?
Is 85% good? Should you aim for 90%? Those are fair questions, but they are not the question most people bring to a planning meeting. The question most people bring is simpler: what do my savings need to earn?
A probability answers how likely your plan is to work. That is a different question.
The real goal
The real goal is to see how to invest your savings to meet your withdrawal needs with the least amount of risk required to keep your principal intact.
That calls for a different kind of number.
One number you can act on
The Retirement Ratio is the earnings rate your portfolio needs to fund your retirement spending without drawing down what you saved. It takes two steps:
- Find your annual gap. Take what you expect to spend in a year and subtract your income sources: Social Security, pensions, rental income.
- Divide by your invested assets. That is your Retirement Ratio.
Take a hypothetical household that spends $90,000 a year, has $48,000 in income sources, and has $1,000,000 invested. Its gap is $42,000, and its Retirement Ratio is 4.2%*. Its portfolio needs to earn 4.2%* a year to cover the gap without drawing down principal.
* Example number for illustration only. This is a hypothetical household and does not represent typical or expected results.
Notice what that number lets you do. It turns "how likely am I to be fine?" into "what does my money need to earn?" And that is a question you can make decisions with:
- How to invest. If your portfolio needs to earn a modest rate, there may be no reason to take more risk than that requires.
- When to start Social Security or a pension. Each choice changes your income, so you can see exactly how it changes your ratio.
- What your spending means for your plan. Every dollar of spending moves your gap, and you can see by how much.
When the number is too high
Now take a second hypothetical household. It spends $100,000 a year, has $40,000 in income sources, and has $1,000,000 invested. Its gap is $60,000, so its Retirement Ratio is 6.0%. I like to see the ten-year average below 5%, so this household has work to do.
The ratio shows where to start. Delaying Social Security to raise it to $46,000 a year brings the ratio to 5.4%. Trimming spending by $8,000 a year on top of that brings it to 4.6%. Two specific changes, each with a size you can see.
Neither number is a forecast; both move with assumptions about spending, inflation and returns. The difference is what each one is built to show. A probability tells you the chance your plan works. The Retirement Ratio tells you what your savings need to earn, and how much risk that takes.
Find your own number
I wrote a free guide that walks through the Retirement Ratio with three worked examples. You can get it at wealthbalanceadvisors.com/free-guide.
Or, if you would rather have your own number, a Retirement Ratio Session gives you your ratio for year one and as a ten-year average, a plan in plain English built around it, and clear next steps. You can book one at wealthbalanceadvisors.com/retirement-ratio-session.
FIND YOUR NUMBER
Get your Retirement Ratio figured
A Retirement Ratio Session gives you your ratio for year one and as a ten-year average, a plan in plain English, and clear next steps. The Session is $350.
Wealth Balance Advisors
Retirement Planning, Simplified.
Birmingham, AL
Client Access
Subscribe to Our Newsletter
Wealth Balance Advisors is an other business name of Independent Advisor Alliance, LLC. All investment advice is offered through Independent Advisor Alliance, LLC, a registered investment adviser. This website is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Past performance is not indicative of future results.
Wealth Balance Advisors
Retirement Planning, Simplified.
Birmingham, AL
Client Access
Subscribe to Our Newsletter
Wealth Balance Advisors is an other business name of Independent Advisor Alliance, LLC. All investment advice is offered through Independent Advisor Alliance, LLC, a registered investment adviser. This website is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Past performance is not indicative of future results.